15 NOV 2026

Faith-eism

A non-believer's spiritual journey through the super and the natural

Josh Ghiloni
@joshghiloni.me


Note: This is a talk I gave at All Souls Unitarian Universalist Church on November 15, 2026

At the Mansfield Pride Parade this year, I was walking with our delegation, right up front, and I was handing out what I can only describe as a zine about UUs and our views on trans rights to folks watching the parade.

I distinctly remember one conversation due to how much it hit me after it was over, never mind how brief it was. I walked up to a group and said "hey, would you like to learn more about Unitarian Universalism?" like I had to every other group, fully expecting them to take a couple and immediately forget about them. I just hoped they wouldn't litter. This time, however, one politely refused and said "sorry, I'm an atheist." I just beamed and said "cool! Me too!" They smiled but weren't interested, so I went on my merry way, pushing my son in his stroller to the next group. This was, by almost any definition, an entirely banal exchange, but it resonated with me.

Who was this person who, 15 years ago, would have laughed you out of a room if you'd even suggested he'd be inviting strangers to a church he truly loved? The same person, who nearly five years ago, when his fiancée encouraged him to try to find a spiritual path, broke down crying on his front porch with his morning coffee as he explained that he couldn't believe in God, because if God was real, then God had abandoned him, not the other way around. He's the same person who, earlier this year, bared his soul to this congregation about the aftermath of his suicide attempt?

He's the same person standing in front of you today, but he's completely different, and what a long, strange trip it's been.

I grew up in a Catholic family; both sides. I don't know if it's still true, but the trophy case at Newark Catholic High School is named after my grandfather. My parents weren't nearly as devout — after their divorce, Sunday School at St Leonard's in Heath was a convenient transfer place for me and my brother. Mom dropped us off and Dad picked us up. We never really went to mass.

Despite all that, I think I've always been an atheist, though I didn't recognize it till I was in my 30s. I've always had an analytic mind, and I've always had a hard time believing things that don't hold up to any rigor. When I was 8 or 9, I took my first Communion, because it wasn't actually presented as an option. I was given the choice, however, to whether or not I would be confirmed in the church. I suppose that's the whole point. I declined because I didn't see the point, which if you think about it, is the entire point.

I wanted to believe, though. I wanted so badly to believe. Licking County is a pretty Christian place, and I saw believers every day, and how happy and fulfilled they seemed.

When I got to college, I was introduced to the International Church of Christ. Back in February, I gave a talk here about my "past lives," meaning the different phases of life I've gone through. I teased the fact that I joined a cult. That's the ICoC.

They did a lot of the classic cult things. They love-bombed me. I felt like I belonged. We had fun. We did what I thought was serious Bible study (though in retrospect I recognized a lot of logical inconsistencies and fallacies.) I got baptized as an adult.

From the beginning, though, I struggled internally. I went through the motions — enthusiastically — but I didn't really believe the dogma. I thought there was something wrong with me, not with the dogma. I was an unemployed, broke student but was still expected to tithe. They didn't like the gentle reminder that 10% of $0 was $0, so I managed to scrape together $5 every week to put in the basket. When I met and connected with a young woman in the congregation, I was told in no uncertain terms that I was too "spiritually young" to even consider dating, and that it would not be allowed. They expressed concern that I wasn't proselytizing frequently enough, and that I had friends outside the church. None of those individually were the proverbial straw that broke the camel's back. I didn't even really recognize it at the time as the cult-like controlling behaviors they were. I don't think they did either, as the Cleveland chapter was a middling tier in the MLM that is any large, distributed cult.

One night, I was deep in an internet rabbit hole (at least, as deep as one could be in 2000) and I came across a site run by and dedicated to people who had left the church. I devoured it over the next few nights and realized how much of myself I saw in it. Finally, on Saturday night, I sent the youth pastor and the young man who'd mentored me an email, pouring my heart out and told them I wasn't going to service the next day, and wouldn't be going back at all. 26 years later, I still remember writing "I don't know if I've lost my faith or if I never had it to begin with." I never saw either of them again, save for a chance encounter with the youth pastor in Raleigh Durham International Airport 6 or 7 years later.

In the immediate aftermath, I missed my friends deeply, but I didn't reach out. I knew the score. I was a fall-away and, to them, I was effectively dead. Hell-bound, for sure, but also a threat. A threat in that I would tempt others to join me in leaving, which was endlessly and morbidly amusing to me. Sure, now I may be a confident public speaker; I might even be convincing in certain contexts. If I'm consulting with your company on enterprise software, I'll tell you exactly what to do, and you'll think it was your idea. I wasn't then, though, and I've never been accused of being a "leader of men." I didn't want to tempt people from the church—in fact, I envied them—and even if I wanted to, I wouldn't have been able to.

What got to me about that though, was how weak it sounded. It was such a contradiction, and a relatively obvious one at that. It's also, if you think about it, a key page of the authoritarian playbook: They are the damned. They are the nonbelievers. We are the saved. We are God's strongest soldiers. We will fall apart with even an inkling of dissent, so we must isolate ourselves to ensure our purity.

When I realized that, a weight was lifted from my shoulders, and I more comfortably embraced my agnosticism (I still wasn't comfortable calling it atheism, because I was hedging my bets).

By the time I graduated college, though, I'd dropped all pretense. We were in two wars that even then seemed unwinnable because they were largely undefined and undefinable. How could God exist in a world like that? I hated religion and blamed it for all the world's woes. It was a tidy answer to all of my spiritual questions.

If you're a member here, you know that tidy answers never last long, and they don't hold up to any kind of sincere questioning. I was in my thirties at this point and my heart and mind (and politics) were drifting closer and closer to the people around me. Why were we, ostensibly the wealthiest country in existence, persistently plagued with neediness and poverty. The inescapable answer (much to my dad's chagrin) was capitalism.

Capitalism isn't really the basis of our economy, despite everyone telling you it is. That is free-market economics, and at its core, I have no problem with the pure definition of the free market. Capitalism, though, is something different entirely. It's a class of people with capital! It's the owner class. The bosses, to use a more dated term. It's the class of people that take our labor and pocket the proceeds, and no matter how well they pay the workers, still just give them the scraps. Dolly Parton was right in her proletarian anthem "9 to 5" — They just use your mind, and you never get the credit. It's enough to drive you crazy if you let it! That's right: Dolly was saying "workers of the world unite" and "no struggle but class struggle" decades before it came into vogue here in the state.

To fight back, I did what I could. I donated my time and money to causes that helped every day people. I tried to explain things to those who would listen, but as anyone with an education background will tell you, if you don't truly understand a concept, you'll never be able to teach it. I was doing my best, and hopefully doing some good, but I wasn't taking care of me. At least, not spiritually. It's like the pre-flight safety briefing they give you every time you get on a plane. I hadn't secured my own mask before attempting to help others with theirs, and it made me, frankly, despondent.

I looked up to, and was deeply jealous of, people in much more precarious situations who still managed to get up every day, look at the world, and say "today, I am going to fight for what is right." I didn't understand until very recently that they weren't necessarily doing it because of some innate ability to rise above. They were, and are, fighting every day because they have to. They fight every day like their lives depend on it because, in many cases, it does.

This brings us back to that summer morning in 2022 on my front porch with my fiancée. I knew she grew up in an evangelical faith tradition, so when she gently encouraged me to embark on a new spiritual journey, my kneejerk reaction was to defensively assume she was suggesting I find Jesus again. That is the reason I reacted the way I did, and after we talked more, I realized that wasn't what she meant. She saw in me something that was missing, and knew the only person who could find that missing piece was me.

I had seen UU churches before and was always curious but had never ventured into one. I decided to change that in August of 2022, a few weeks after that conversation, when I first stepped foot in here, and was welcomed so warmly by Chuck and Ed. I believe Reverend Will spoke on that first visit, though I can't be sure. All I knew was that what I heard was compelling, and filled me up, and I couldn't wait to come back again, this time with her in tow. I was, from the first moment, hooked.

Since that time, I've been introduced to so many topics, and belief systems, from Judaism to Buddhism, indigenous faith traditions to more modern concepts like humanism. I'm still an atheist, but I've learned so much from everything here.

Most importantly, and the thing about Unitarian Universalism that keeps bringing me back, is the concept that we are covenantal, not creedal. We don't care what you believe; you're still welcome here. What we care about is how you act in, and interact with, the world around you.

Consider our official shared values with the extremely catchy mnemonic, as coined by Joan, JETPIG, and taken from the UAA Beliefs Page:

Justice: We work to be diverse multicultural Beloved Communities where all feel welcome and can thrive. We work to dismantle racism and all forms of systemic oppression. We support the use of inclusive democratic processes to make decisions within our congregations, our Association, and society at large.

Justice has been at the forefront of my mind for nearly 20 years. True justice, that is; not criminal justice, which in our society is little more than state-sanctioned retribution and punishment. True justice works to right wrongs, make reparations and take preventive steps to stop it in the future.

Equity: We declare that every person is inherently worthy and has the right to flourish with dignity, love, and compassion. We use our time, wisdom, attention, and money to build and sustain fully accessible and inclusive communities.

More than equality, equity is ensuring that everyone is on a level playing field, not that everyone gets the same assistance. Let's pretend we're standing in front of a set of shelves, where higher shelves hold progressively higher sums of money. I'm 6'3. Equity is giving Cheryl a step stool so she can reach the same shelves I can. Equality is giving us both the same step stool. Only one of those options actually levels the playing field.

Transformation: We adapt to the changing world. We collectively transform and grow spiritually and ethically. Openness to change is fundamental to our Unitarian and Universalist heritages, never complete and never perfect.

Adaptation is not only natural, it's so natural that it's key to survival. It's literally one of the fundamental underpinnings of evolution. "Survival of the fittest" isn't about which individuals are the biggest or strongest or fastest; it's about which populations can adapt to their environments most effectively, and UUs excel here.

Pluralism: We are all sacred beings, diverse in culture, experience, and theology. We learn from one another in our free and responsible search for truth and meaning. We embrace our differences and commonalities with Love, curiosity, and respect.

A slightly more acerbic way to phrase this is something a lot of atheists say to Christians: "Over the years, people have worshipped thousands of gods. You worship one. I worship none." What's left out of that, and shouldn't be, is the implication that in the grand scheme of things, we're really not that different. Learn from people different from you, if you can.

Interdependence: We honor the interdependent web of all existence and acknowledge our place in it. With reverence for the great web of life and with humility, we acknowledge our place in it. We work to protect Earth and all beings from exploitation. We create and nurture sustainable relationships of care and respect, mutuality and justice. We will work to repair harm and damaged relationships.

No man is an island, and every action we take has potentially deep, long term effects. Think for example if we were able to eradicate the scourge of every humid summer: the mosquito. There would be massive ripples in food webs across the animal kingdoms, primarily in the Arctic tundra. Bet you didn't see that coming! Would it be an ecological disaster? Scientists don't think so, but they don't know. Any dramatic steps taken by our uniquely sapient species can never be done in a vacuum, and we must respect that, or reap the whirlwinds that follow.

Generosity: We cultivate a spirit of gratitude and hope. We freely and compassionately share our faith, presence, and resources. Our generosity connects us to one another in relationships of interdependence and mutuality.

To me, generosity isn't just a fundamental value of Unitarian Universalism; it's a part of the natural order and mandate as a species to ensure our survival. Taking is an act of violence at its core; giving is an act of love and recognition that we are all in this together.

More than anything else, being in this community has enriched me spiritually, emotionally, and mentally because it has helped me name what I truly believe and give it structure, which my brain and body crave. With this structure, I can focus my energy and spirit on furthering my goals and spend less time trying to put words to things that already have descriptions. For years to come, my fervent desire is to come to this place for fulfillment and refinement. Your love fills my heart. Your words fill my soul. Your acts refine my own, and help me stay on the path I have chosen for myself. I hope that I, in my small way, do that for you too.

Thank you for letting me ramble. I love this place. I love this community. I love you.

faithpublic-speakingunitarian-universalism

Enjoyed this article?

Join our free newsletter and never miss an update.


Related Articles